Time-Weighted vs Money-Weighted Return, Explained

Time-weighted return measures how the investments performed, with the effect of your deposits and withdrawals removed. Money-weighted return measures what your actual money earned, so the size and timing of every deposit and withdrawal counts.
The two can point in opposite directions for the same account in the same year. That’s not an error. They answer different questions, and knowing which one you’re looking at stops a broker statement from confusing you.
What is time-weighted return?
In the CFA Institute’s Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS), time-weighted return is defined as “a method of calculating period-by-period returns that reflects the change in value and negates the effects of external cash flows” (GIPS 2020). An external cash flow is money or securities entering or leaving the portfolio: your deposits, withdrawals and transfers.
The calculation splits the period at every cash flow. Interactive Brokers’ white paper describes it this way:
- Break the period into sub-periods, starting a new one at each deposit or withdrawal.
- Work out each sub-period’s return: ending value divided by (beginning value plus the cash flow), minus 1.
- Link the sub-period returns geometrically: multiply (1 + each return) together and subtract 1.
Because every sub-period starts fresh after a cash flow, the amount of money in the account doesn’t affect the result. A 20% gain counts as 20% whether it happened on $1,000 or on $100,000.
What is money-weighted return?
GIPS defines money-weighted return as “the return for a period that reflects the change in value and the timing and size of external cash flows.” IBKR’s white paper says it is used “when you are trying to measure the performance experienced by an investor.”
The classic way to compute it is the internal rate of return (IRR): the single rate that, applied to each deposit for as long as it was invested, grows everything to the ending value. Solving for it takes trial and error, so some brokers, IBKR’s PortfolioAnalyst among them, use the Modified Dietz method instead. It divides the gain (ending value minus beginning value minus net deposits) by the beginning value plus each deposit weighted by the share of the period it was invested. For a single mid-period deposit, the two methods land close together.
A money-weighted return rewards money that arrived before good stretches and punishes money that arrived before bad ones. That makes it a measure of your experience, including your timing decisions.
A worked example: same year, two answers
Here is a hypothetical account over one year, with round numbers.
- 1 January: you start with $10,000.
- 30 June: the portfolio is up 20%, to $12,000. Encouraged, you deposit $20,000, so the account holds $32,000.
- 31 December: the second half is down 10%, and the account ends at $28,800.
The time-weighted return links the two halves: 1.20 × 0.90 − 1 = 8.0%. The investments did their job over the year, so this figure is positive.
Your dollars tell a different story. You put in $30,000 in total and ended with $28,800, a loss of $1,200. Modified Dietz gives −1,200 divided by (10,000 + 20,000 × 0.5), which is −1,200 / 20,000 = −6.0%. The IRR comes out at about −5.95%. Two-thirds of your money arrived just before the bad half, so your dollars lost money in a year when the strategy gained 8%.
Reverse the timing and the gap flips. Had the $20,000 gone in on 1 January and the account then gained 20% and lost 10%, both measures would show 8%, because there would be no mid-year cash flow to weight.
Why do the two returns differ?
They differ only when money moves in or out, and the gap grows with the size of those flows relative to the account. With no deposits or withdrawals, both methods give the same number.
Read the direction of the gap as a note on timing. A money-weighted return below the time-weighted one means more of your money was invested during the weaker stretches. A money-weighted return above it means your deposits happened to land before the stronger ones. Small regular contributions tend to leave a smaller gap than one large lump sum, because each flow is small next to the account, and a lump sum can move it a lot, as the example shows.
Neither figure is the “real” return. An 8% time-weighted return and a −6% money-weighted return are both correct descriptions of the same account.
Which return answers which question?
Use time-weighted return to judge a strategy or a manager, because it removes cash flows that the manager doesn’t control. That’s why GIPS requires investment firms to present time-weighted returns, and allows money-weighted returns only when the firm controls the cash flows and the fund is closed-end, fixed-life, fixed-commitment or has illiquid investments as a significant part of its strategy.
Money-weighted return is the one to read for what happened to your money. If you want to know whether your contributions grew, it’s the closer answer. A fair comparison of your stock picking against an index fund calls for time-weighted return on both sides; a check on whether your own buying and selling helped calls for comparing the two.
Brokers show different ones. On an IBKR Activity Statement, the NAV section prints a Time Weighted Rate of Return, which IBKR says “measures the percent return produced over time independent of contributions or withdrawals.” IBKR’s PortfolioAnalyst lets you switch between cumulative return (time-weighted) and period return (money-weighted) (IBKR). Other brokers may show only one, so check which before comparing two accounts.
How do you work out both from your own numbers?
You need the account value at the start and end of the period, every deposit and withdrawal with its date, and, for the time-weighted figure, the account value just before each of those flows. Here is a second hypothetical year with two flows.
- 1 January: $50,000.
- 1 April: the account is worth $51,000, and you deposit $6,000.
- 1 October: it is worth $54,500, and you withdraw $4,000.
- 31 December: it ends at $55,000.
For the time-weighted return, take each stretch on its own. January to March: 51,000 / 50,000 − 1 = 2.0%. April to September started at $57,000 after the deposit and ended at $54,500, so −4.4%. October to December started at $50,500 after the withdrawal and ended at $55,000, so +8.9%. Linked: 1.020 × 0.956 × 1.089 − 1 = 6.2%.
Modified Dietz starts from the gain: 55,000 − 50,000 − (6,000 − 4,000) = $3,000. Weight each flow by the share of the year it was in the account: the deposit counts for nine months (0.75), the withdrawal for three (0.25). The denominator is 50,000 + 6,000 × 0.75 − 4,000 × 0.25 = 53,500. That gives 3,000 / 53,500 = 5.6%.
This year the money-weighted figure sits a little below the time-weighted one, because the deposit landed just before the weakest stretch. A spreadsheet handles more flows the same way, one row per date.
How FinCoach AI shows your returns
FinCoach AI reads returns from your Interactive Brokers Activity Statement. Upload the PDF on the Trading Patterns tab of the Portfolio page and Claude extracts the headline stats: NAV for the period, NAV Change from the starting value, the Time-Weighted Return printed on the statement, dividends, commissions, interest and realized P&L. The same screen shows trade counts, average holding period, biggest win and loss, fees paid and per-symbol performance.
Upload a new statement each month or quarter and the Trading History tab lines the imports up: NAV across imports, the change in realized P&L, and positions added, closed or resized since the previous statement. Comparing NAV change with the time-weighted figure is a quick way to see how much of the growth came from your deposits.
FinCoach doesn’t calculate a money-weighted return. The time-weighted figure comes from IBKR’s own calculation on the statement, not from FinCoach. If you want a money-weighted number, the Modified Dietz formula above works with three numbers from the Change in NAV section: starting value, ending value and deposits, plus the dates of those deposits. AI extraction can misread a page, so compare the headline numbers with your PDF.
Keep reading
- IBKR Activity Statement explained
- How much to invest per month to reach a goal
- Compound interest calculator
- Common trading mistakes and how to spot them
Educational, not financial advice. FinCoach AI is not a broker or investment adviser, and AI output can be wrong; check anything important before you act. Figures as of 31 October 2026; sources linked.
Upload an IBKR statement and compare your NAV change with your TWR. Launch the app.
Launch appFrequently asked questions
Is time-weighted or money-weighted return better?
Neither is better in general. Time-weighted return judges the investments or the manager because it removes deposits and withdrawals. Money-weighted return shows what your own money earned, including the effect of when you added or withdrew it.
Why is my money-weighted return lower than my time-weighted return?
More of your money was invested during the weaker part of the period. A large deposit just before a fall, for example, pulls the money-weighted return down while the time-weighted return is unaffected.
Is money-weighted return the same as IRR?
IRR is the standard way to calculate a money-weighted return. Some brokers, Interactive Brokers among them, use the Modified Dietz method instead because it needs no trial and error. In simple cases like a single mid-year deposit it lands close to the IRR.
Which return does Interactive Brokers show?
The Activity Statement prints a Time Weighted Rate of Return in its Net Asset Value section. IBKR’s PortfolioAnalyst lets you choose between cumulative return, which is time-weighted, and period return, which is money-weighted.
Do the two returns match if I never deposit or withdraw?
Yes. With no external cash flows during the period, both methods measure the same change in value and give the same result.
This article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. FinCoach AI is not a broker or registered investment adviser. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of capital. Do your own research and consider a licensed professional before acting. See our Terms.